Monday, November 21, 2005

the concept of responsibility (part 2 of 3)

This is my second day of discussion concerning the topic of free-will. Below is an excerpt from an article discussing how a person's environment affects who they are and the decisions they make. I have pulled out the juicy, fun-to-read parts for you:

You will often hear arguments that we can't hold people responsible for what they do if what they do is determined by their heredity or environment. This is the basis for a lot of the criticism directed against predestination. If God knows that someone is going to sin, and in fact if God has overall responsibility for the history of which this action is a part, then it's God's fault. The person is being forced to sin, so he is not responsible.

There is a growing tendency not to hold people responsible if we can see how their environment affected them. People can almost always find some way of blaming what they are on something else. Thus the concept of responsibility is quickly vanishing altogether, or being applied in incoherent ways.

Indeed because the person's character, motivations, and situation is under God's control, there's a sense in which we can say that God determined the action. But his plan is carried out by the working out of human decisions and other historical causes.

The balance of responsibility is somewhat different with those who are God's children and those who are not. With those who are saved, God operates in a personal way, through the presence of the Holy Spirit and our union with Christ. While we make responsible choices, the basic decision to save us is God's. There is no equivalent for those who reject God. While their rejection is part of an overall history for which God is responsible, God does not take specific actions to make them reject him, as he takes actions to redeem his children.

Here are some articles that may be of interest for those of you concerned with the topic of free will:

5 comments:

Jen said...

Woohoo! I see you got the link thing figured out. Looks good.

Jeanna said...

Nice movement of the links...how'd ya do it?

Stephen Hinkel said...

That is a flippin' sweet picture! Wow!

Sarah B said...

Hey Jon, i love it...that's a topic I can talk about for quite some time...anyways i love you blog...awesome im glad i had time to sit down and read it =)

Jeanna said...

So I am still waiting for part 3...